By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
azemedia-new-logo
  • Donation
  • Who we are
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • News
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Ecology
  • Culture
  • Diaspora
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • Gender
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
Aze.Media
Aa
Search
  • News
  • Economy
  • Ecology
  • Energy
  • Opinion
  • Culture
  • Gender
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
  • Diaspora
  • Who we are
Follow US
© 2021 Aze.Media – Daily Digest
Aze.Media > Karabakh > Why Karabakh does need autonomous status in Azerbaijan
Karabakh

Why Karabakh does need autonomous status in Azerbaijan

The small number of 25,000 Armenians continuing to live in Karabakh are too small in number to require an autonomous republic.

AzeMedia
By AzeMedia Published May 21, 2022 9 Min Read
000_8TC842
An Armenian soldier walks at the frontline in Karabakh [Aris Messinis/ AFP]

Meanwhile, keeping 2,000 Russian peacekeeping forces in place is a bad policy option as their primary goal will be to keep tensions simmering between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Without these tensions there would be no use for Russia’s so-called peacekeepers.  Russian peacekeepers have been stationed in Moldova’s Transniestr and Georgia’s South Ossetia and Abkhazia for three decades and have never attempted to resolve these conflicts. This is because the Kremlin prefers to keep these conflicts frozen to provide continued justification for the presence of its so-called peacekeepers.

The creation of autonomous republics, territories and oblasts have never been a panacea for national minorities. In fact, the creation of autonomous regions, devolution of power and creation of regional parliaments has always increased the appetite of national minorities by encouraging them to become separatists.

Providing autonomy to the Catalans, Quebecois and Scottish did not end conflicts between them and central governments. It merely set the Catalans, Quebecois and Scots on a separatist road to breaking away from Spain, Canada, and the UK respectively.

The situation on the ground has fundamentally changed as a consequence of ethnic cleansing that took place in the First Karabakh War in 1988-1994. Then Armenian forces expelled nearly three quarter of a million Azerbaijani’s, three times more than the Armenians who were expelled from Azerbaijan. Irrespective of where blame lies, the resultant outcome was that Azerbaijan and Armenia are now to all intents and purposes mono-ethnic countries.

The absence of minority problems in both countries should make negotiating a post-conflict peace treaty easier and after it is signed, more durable. National minorities have always created difficulties for negotiators attempting to craft treaties that recognise borders and the territorial integrity of states.

There are four aspects that need to be taken into account by Western policymakers working to bring lasting peace to the South Caucasus.

The first is to accept there has not been a “Nagorno-Karabakh” for over three decades. The Soviet era Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast (NKAO) was abolished as far back as November 1991.

The second factor is that it is wrong to call the region the “Republic of Artsakh” as this gives support to Armenian separatists who seek to break away from Azerbaijan and unite with Armenia. This would be the same as calling the Chechen region of Russia as the “Chechen Republic of Ichkeria.”

The third factor is Karabakh never had territorial links to Armenia and the goal of Armenian nationalists therefore during the First Karabakh War was to occupy all of the lands surrounding the NKAO. This led to Armenia occupying a fifth of Azerbaijani territory from 1994 until 2020. During the occupation, the Armenian authorities purposefully destroyed or looted practically every building, as is evident when one takes a tour, as I have, of the liberated areas. Worse still, the Armenian authorities did not encourage any economic development and foreign investment into these occupied territories or the settlement of the large territory it occupied by Armenians.

The final factor is the very small number of Armenians living in Karabakh should be not part of any negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan on a post-conflict peace treaty. Armenians living in Karabakh should directly negotiate with the Azerbaijani authorities about receiving some form of self-governing status that would permit education, culture, media, and other areas to be delegated to their representatives. In the case of the Karabakh region, the new self-governing status should not include “autonomy” in its official title which would send a signal that the separatist question is dead and buried.

Negotiations will only be successful between the Armenian minority and Baku when the 10,000 Armenian forces are withdrawn from Karabakh. Their presence is illegal under article four of the 2020 ceasefire agreement which states: “The peacekeeping contingent of the Russian Federation is being deployed in parallel with the withdrawal of the Armenian armed forces. The term of stay of the peacekeeping contingent of the Russian Federation is 5 years with automatic extension for the next 5-year periods, if none of the Parties declares 6 months before the expiration of the period of intention to terminate the application of this provision.”

These illegal Armenian forces are preventing negotiations from taking place that would give the Armenian minority some form of rights.  Their withdrawal is not taking place because Armenian nationalists refuse to accept the new realities arising from their defeat in the Second Karabakh War and they continue to support the unification of Karabakh with Armenia; that is, they constitute a threat to the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan. Meanwhile, the Kremlin is not implementing the ceasefire agreement knowing full well that Armenian forces remaining in Karabakh will prevent a post-conflict peace treaty being signed.

The small Armenian minority in Karabakh should negotiate with Baku the panoply of rights that they need to maintain their language, culture, and history. To achieve this they need to accept they will be living in Azerbaijan, support the withdrawal of illegal Armenian forces and union with Armenia will not happen.

Such a development would end the traumatic ethnic conflict that has plagued Armenia-Azerbaijani relations since the late 1980s. Armenians living in Azerbaijan would benefit from a post-conflict peace treaty that would bring economic development to their region and the entire South Caucasus.

Taras Kuzio, Research Fellow at the Henry Jackson Society and Professor of Political science at the National University of Kyiv Mohyla Academy. Author of the just published Russian Nationalism and the Russian-Ukrainian War.

cropped-newerlogo250-1

You Might Also Like

The 2nd Azerbaijan National Urban Forum was held in Zangilan President Ilham Aliyev addressed opening ceremony

Amirbekov: Armenians who left Azerbaijan will be able to return

Azerbaijan announces the commencement of registration for Armenians in Karabakh

Three years pass since start of Second Garabagh War

Statement from the Presidential Administration: Vice Premier to hold meetings in Khankendi

AzeMedia May 21, 2022

New articles

gruz-rossiya-karabah1
“Humanitarian aid” or discrimination?
Opinion October 1, 2023
UN Mission in Karabakh
News October 1, 2023
Azeri-military-in-nagorno-karabakh-scaled-1
Azerbaijan Army’s serviceman becomes Martyr as a result of sniper fire from territory of Armenia
News September 30, 2023
maxresdefault
Eldar Namazov: How is it possible for 1500 people to pass through the Border Checkpoint in an hour?
Interview September 30, 2023
Arz Ira Branded
Can Israelis help achieve Azerbaijani-Armenian peace?
Opinion September 30, 2023
1_pSMkIZSfuCUgHmPIST5xCg
Azerbaijan-Armenia conflict: Beyond common belief
Opinion September 30, 2023
d9342164-1f07-33c3-ba19-16a0c82f9f16_850
MFA: Further requests submitted by Armenia to ICJ are completely unfounded and absurd
News September 30, 2023
OON-1
UNHCR: No information on ill-treatment of Armenians leaving Karabakh
News September 30, 2023
Azerbaijan-Armenia-_-Svet-foto-750-500
Russia’s loss and Azerbaijan’s victory is in the West’s interest
Opinion September 29, 2023
169597291399739617_1200x630
The 2nd Azerbaijan National Urban Forum was held in Zangilan President Ilham Aliyev addressed opening ceremony
Karabakh September 29, 2023

You Might Also Like

169597291399739617_1200x630

The 2nd Azerbaijan National Urban Forum was held in Zangilan President Ilham Aliyev addressed opening ceremony

September 29, 2023 41 Min Read
c870307b-77c0-3921-8ce1-ab2b1c2e0a26_850

Amirbekov: Armenians who left Azerbaijan will be able to return

September 28, 2023 2 Min Read
Screenshot_1-21-1536x780

Azerbaijan announces the commencement of registration for Armenians in Karabakh

September 28, 2023 2 Min Read
esger

Three years pass since start of Second Garabagh War

September 27, 2023 7 Min Read
F63L0u_WoAAUOwJ

Statement from the Presidential Administration: Vice Premier to hold meetings in Khankendi

September 25, 2023 4 Min Read
2d6302e1-84a1-3b44-8de3-dddc0501ed60

Amount of products included in aid sent to civilians living in Karabakh announced

September 22, 2023 1 Min Read
16952974913378055859_1200x630

The Aliyev Administration on the outcomes of the meeting in Yevlakh

September 21, 2023 3 Min Read
293192

Azerbaijan hosts meeting with Karabakh separatists after cease-fire

September 21, 2023 3 Min Read

Useful links

c24a7d34-02d2-45a2-95ad-980aa8264ad5-pojkz9yv6xhhbce432wwxbxmnoy6uz3duxvaa480e8
426082d1-a9e4-4ac5-95d4-4e84024eb314-pojkz91103g6zqfh8kiacu662b2tn9znit7ssu9ekg
ab65ed96-2f4a-4220-91ac-f70a6daaf659-pojkz67iflcc0wjkp1aencvsa5gq06ogif9cd0dl34
96e40a2b-5fed-4332-83c6-60e4a89fd4d0-pojkz836t9ewo4gue23nscepgx7gfkvx6okbbkasqo
759bde00-a375-4fa1-bedc-f8e9580ceeca-pq8mvb9kwubqf6bcadpkq5mz16nayr162k3j2084cg
aze-media-logo-ag1

Aze.Media offers an independent and strategic insight on socio-cultural, political and economic life in Azerbaijan.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookies Policy

Email: editor@aze.media

© 2023 Aze.Media – Daily Digest

Removed from reading list

Undo
aze-media-logo1 aze-media-logo-ag1
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?