By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Azemedia New Logo
  • Donation
  • Who we are
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • News
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Ecology
  • Culture
  • Diaspora
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • Gender
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
Aze.Media
Aa
Search
  • News
  • Economy
  • Ecology
  • Energy
  • Opinion
  • Culture
  • Gender
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
  • Diaspora
  • Who we are
Follow US
© 2021 Aze.Media – Daily Digest
Aze.Media > Karabakh > Armenia may recognize Karabakh as legally Azerbaijani only if Russia retains de facto control
Karabakh

Armenia may recognize Karabakh as legally Azerbaijani only if Russia retains de facto control

It is possible to argue that the weightiest consequence of the 44-day war between Armenia and Azerbaijan in September–November 2020 was not Baku’s victory over Armenian forces but rather the return of Russian troops to the region in the form of “peacekeepers” in Karabakh.

AzeMedia
By AzeMedia Published April 27, 2022 10 Min Read
554516 Src
The Russian peacekeeper somehow forgot that the separatist is not his brother

And even though those Russian soldiers are supposed to remain for only five years, their presence effectively seems to have marked the establishment of a Russian protectorate there—one that will not end anytime soon (see EDM, March 18, 22, 23, 2021; Ekho Kavkaza, April 15, 2022).

Developments in the Armenian-Azerbaijani peace talks over recent weeks seem to make such an outcome even more likely, allowing Moscow to recover its position in Armenia, increase its leverage over Azerbaijan, and potentially freeze out the West from any future discussions about the Karabakh conflict (see EDM, April 14). At least superficially, Russian-backed moves may make it appear that the goal the West has long sought—Armenian recognition of the 1991 borders with Azerbaijan—has finally been achieved; but in reality, that goal will have been gained at the price of Russian forces indefinitely taking on the role of occupiers. But precisely for those reasons, the long-running conflict over Karabakh will not so much end as change shape, with the axis of hostilities moving from one between Armenia and Azerbaijan to one between both of those countries and the Russian Federation. Consequently, Moscow could end up losing more than it expects to gain.

Beniamin Pogosian, the head of the Yerevan-based Center for Political and Economic Strategic Research, suggested all of these possibilities in an important new interview with Vadim Dubnov of the Ekho Kavkaza portal. The Armenian scholar argued that Armenia, in response to pressure from Moscow and the West, may acknowledge de jure that Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan and, thus, be willing to delimit and demarcate the borders between Armenia and Azerbaijan. But crucially, Armenia would probably agree to this solely on the condition that Karabakh remains de facto under Russian control. That is not a perfect solution, Pogosian conceded, but it gives Armenians in Armenia and in Karabakh the best chance to block Azerbaijan from launching any broadscale attacks on Armenian interests while talks about some final autonomy for Karabakh continue (Ekho Kavkaza, April 15).

According to the analyst, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian recently said that “the international community is telling Armenia it must forget about the independence of Nagorno-Karabakh [sic] and agree to some sort of autonomy for it within Azerbaijan.” Behind the Armenian leader’s words, Pogosian asserted, is recognition that if Yerevan refuses to do so and abstains from border delimitation and autonomy for Karabakh (talks that could go on for years), Baku will sooner or later launch a military campaign to recover the rest of this territory. And the international community will stand aside, telling Yerevan that it had warned the Armenians of what would happen if they did not agree to the West’s proposals, Pogosian predicted (Ekho Kavkaza, April 15).

Of course, as Pashinian himself acknowledged, this would represent a break from the position Armenia has maintained since 1988 and would put the 100,000 ethnic Armenians of Karabakh at risk unless there is some other protector. The only available candidate, the Center for Political and Economic Strategic Research analyst insisted, consists of the Russian peacekeepers, whose presence facilitates the necessary condition for Yerevan to make the concession the international community is demanding. That has the effect of putting the West in an awkward position: the United States and the European Union want an end to the conflict, but they also want to reduce Russian influence. Yet Moscow is increasingly ignoring them (Ekho Kavkaza, April 15). Indeed, Russia has declared that the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict will be addressed not by the defunct Minsk Group but by a special Russian representative (see EDM, April 21).

As long as Armenia keeps talking and Russian forces remain in Karabakh, Azerbaijan is unlikely to launch a military campaign either there or elsewhere; the damage to its relations with Western countries would be too great, Pogosian contended. Thus, if Armenia agrees to acknowledge that Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan de jure, Moscow may have found a way to maintain its forces in that region for a long time to come—and with at least unspoken if begrudging Western support. Given this, the Armenian analyst said, Russia is confident that Karabakh must de jure be part of Azerbaijan but de facto under Russian control, somewhat imitating its approach to Abkhazia and South Ossetia between 1994 and 2008 (Ekho Kavkaza, April 15). Of course, as Pogosian does not mention, Russia ultimately changed course, invaded Georgia and recognized the two separatist statelets as “independent”—a fact that many in Azerbaijan and the West are all too well aware of.

Some diplomats suggest Baku will accept this arrangement because “there is not that big a difference as to who controls an occupied territory if it is not you.” But many in Azerbaijan see things differently. They view the Russian occupiers as illegitimate and want them withdrawn. If Russia’s “peacekeepers” remain, and if they continue to work closely with Armenian officials, such demands from Azerbaijan will only increase, particularly given the increasing Russian aggressiveness in Ukraine and elsewhere (Windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com, January 31; Meduza, March 27). Such possibilities simultaneously limit Moscow’s options and set the stage for new conflicts between Azerbaijan and Russia in the future.

But the de jure/de facto compromise, which now appears to be on the table, may backfire on Russia in Armenia as well. Karabakh has been too central for too long in Armenian politics for most Armenians to be happy about such an arrangement. Key political figures in Yerevan as well as many regular Armenians will see this “trade” as a betrayal of their national interests. Their anger may focus first and foremost on the Pashinian government. But over time, especially if the Kremlin tries to curry favor with Azerbaijan for other reasons by changing its approach in Karabakh, Armenia’s fury will likely refocus on Russia, however much of a traditional ally Yerevan has long been to Moscow.

Paul Goble

Eurasia Daily Monitor 

You Might Also Like

Sons of Ganja: The dream of Karabakh’s reunion with Azerbaijan

President of Azerbaijan: Liberation of Aghdam, Lachin, Kalbajar without single shot being fired saved lives of thousands of our young people

Downturn in Karabakh?

Shusha – a priceless treasure among mountains

Azerbaijanis long to return to their homeland, but face challenges and uncertainties

AzeMedia April 27, 2022

New articles

080423c8bd512aaac24e7d85c701d3359bae4b
Speaker of the Armenian Parliament: There is no longer a Karabakh issue, we support the integrity of Azerbaijan
News November 28, 2023
1585840780 3950057 1585840663 9313655406236125
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Azerbaijan called the ambassadors of the United States, Germany, and France on the carpet
News November 28, 2023
Flag,of,armenia,flag,of,azerbaijan,nagorno Karabakh,conflict
Azerbaijan and Armenia may sign a peace treaty by December 15, it was stated in Yerevan
News November 28, 2023
Alen Simonyan 07 04 23 1024x683
Alen Simonyan: Over time, if they wish, Azerbaijanis will be able to settle in Armenia
News November 28, 2023
Ilham Aliyev Blinken 260722 2
Blinken called Aliyev with an important request, the president allowed O’Brien to fly to Baku
News November 28, 2023
Bigstock Cargo Ship Loading Cargo Conta 470130049 1320x742
With the right policies and investment, the Middle Corridor can be more than a land bridge from East to West
Logistics-Transport November 28, 2023
Thumbs B C 75dbe1cc982c09aa66c710bc83345d35
Güler: Karabakh will forever remain Azerbaijani territory
News November 27, 2023
Chelik
Çelik: The United States has demanded that Turkey cease its support for Azerbaijan
News November 27, 2023
Vstrecha Ministrov Oborony Azerbajdzhana Gruzii I Turtsii 2
A trilateral meeting of the defense ministers of Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Turkey took place in Baku
Defense November 27, 2023
1d3054e3 C4e4 3b9a 90f1 E509cf65765f 850
Hasanov: The importance of peace, stability, security, and mutual cooperation in the region is emphasized
Defense November 27, 2023

You Might Also Like

17242892 0 17 4240 1822

Sons of Ganja: The dream of Karabakh’s reunion with Azerbaijan

November 10, 2023 11 Min Read
9c52398a 2fea 3e01 8997 Dfc548179ac6 850

President of Azerbaijan: Liberation of Aghdam, Lachin, Kalbajar without single shot being fired saved lives of thousands of our young people

November 8, 2023 2 Min Read
Bnegeneric Armenia Azerbaijan Nagorno Karabakh Cropped

Downturn in Karabakh?

October 26, 2023 12 Min Read
Susa Shusha Fortress Photo © Retan Shutterstock 2161373229 1024x683

Shusha – a priceless treasure among mountains

October 25, 2023 8 Min Read
Download (1)

Azerbaijanis long to return to their homeland, but face challenges and uncertainties

October 16, 2023 5 Min Read
C3cd2c51f5ba40114ec38c594fdf42c3

Azerbaijan President raises national flag in Khankendi

October 16, 2023 29 Min Read

Delegation of Russian MoD leaves for Armenia to discuss withdrawal of peacekeepers from Karabakh

October 6, 2023 0 Min Read
Nikol Pashinyan (1)

Pashinyan officially acknowledged in Granada the belonging of Karabakh to Azerbaijan

October 5, 2023 0 Min Read

Useful links

426082d1 A9e4 4ac5 95d4 4e84024eb314 Pojkz91103g6zqfh8kiacu662b2tn9znit7ssu9ekg
Ab65ed96 2f4a 4220 91ac F70a6daaf659 Pojkz67iflcc0wjkp1aencvsa5gq06ogif9cd0dl34
96e40a2b 5fed 4332 83c6 60e4a89fd4d0 Pojkz836t9ewo4gue23nscepgx7gfkvx6okbbkasqo
759bde00 A375 4fa1 Bedc F8e9580ceeca Pq8mvb9kwubqf6bcadpkq5mz16nayr162k3j2084cg
aze-media-logo-ag1

Aze.Media offers an independent and strategic insight on socio-cultural, political and economic life in Azerbaijan.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookies Policy

Email: editor@aze.media

© 2023 Aze.Media – Daily Digest

Removed from reading list

Undo
aze-media-logo1 aze-media-logo-ag1
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?