By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Azemedia new logo
  • Home
  • COP29
  • Opinion
  • News
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Climate and Ecology
  • Culture
  • Diaspora
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • Gender
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
Aze.MediaAze.Media
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • News
  • Economy
  • Climate and Ecology
  • Energy
  • Opinion
  • Culture
  • Gender
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
  • Diaspora
  • Who we are
Follow US
© 2021 Aze.Media – Daily Digest
Aze.Media > Opinion > Protests in Armenia: The rise of the Church or the revanchist efforts of the Ancien régime?
Opinion

Protests in Armenia: The rise of the Church or the revanchist efforts of the Ancien régime?

The statement issued after the 8th meeting between the border determination commissions of Azerbaijan and Armenia on Qazakh-Ijevan border, regarding the return of four non-enclave villages of Qazakh triggered protests in Armenia.

AzeMedia
By AzeMedia Published May 15, 2024 15 Min Read
A13jpeg 1715671282

The protests, which had previously taken place in Kirants, Voskepar and Noyamberyan villages of the Tavush region, reached the capital Yerevan. The leader of the protests was Archbishop Bagrat Galastanyan, who serves as primate of the Tavush Diocese. Galastanyan, who previously held the position of archbishop in the Armenian diocese of Canada, openly proclaimed himself a revanchist during a Sunday sermon. He asserted that revange is the way to reclaiming one’s homeland. Moreover, Galastanyan’s influence extends beyond mere rhetoric; the Tavush church, with his supoort conducts military training for children, promoting Garegin Nzdeh nationalism.

According to Armenian sources, between 20,000-30,000 people attended the protest in Yerevan’s Republic Square on May 9.

Archbishop Galastanyan, who appeared on stage in white religious clothing, accused the Armenian government of destroying the country’s security system, of political failure and making the church a target. He gave Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan one hour to resign. Time expired, but Pashinyan did not resign. Meanwhile, many government members, including Nikol Pashinyan’s press secretary Nazeli Baghdasaryan, shared Nikol Pashinyan’s photo on their social media accounts and wrote that he was the leader elected by the people. When Pashinyan did not resign within an hour, the archbishop stated that their next goal was to dismiss the prime minister with a vote of no confidence in the parliament and met with two opposition parties on this issue after the rally. However, out of 107 seats in the parliament, only 35 belong to the opposition blocs, and they need one vote to submit a vote of no confidence.

In the following days, civil disobedience actions were carried out throughout the country upon the call of Galastanyan. Protesters temporarily blocked the Armenia-Iran and Armenia-Georgia roads. Some students at Yerevan State University boycotted classes and blocked roads various parts of Yerevan.

Galastanyan’s fiery outbursts on the first day did not help him in the following days. The civil disobedience actions that took place were on a smaller scale and the police had no difficulty in controlling the situation. According to the Armenian media report, more than 150 people were detained.

The protests held on May 10 and 12 were attended by one-third as many people as those who attended the previous protest. Speaking on the stage, Galastanyan said that he met with Ishkahn Zakaryan, an independent MP who once served in different positions during the Kocharyan and Sarkisian period, and that the MP would participate in the vote of no confidence in Pashinyan. But in order for the vote of no confidence to pass the parliament, the votes of 54 deputies are needed, which means that Galastanyan must convince the deputies from Pashinyan’s party.

The protests led by Bagrat Galastanyan gave a feeling of ‘déjà vu’.

In terms of its organization, this protest resembled the unsuccessful sequel of the 2018 Velvet Revolution, which brought Nikol Pashinyan to power.

Two years ago, similar protests were organized against the goverment and the peace process organized by ARF-Dashnaktsutyun, Robert Kocharyan and Serzh Sargsyan parties. Bagrat Galastanyan, who said he had no connection with the old regime, appeared on stage during failed 2022 protests and spoke to the public against the peace agreement.

This time, addressing the crowds under the banner of ‘Armenian, Armenia, Motherland, and God’, Galastanyan lacked a forward-thinking strategy, a concrete solution, or any proposal beyond advocating for war. Supported by the opposition, the archbishop’s populist rhetoric and utopian promises fell short in persuading the public to consider a change in government.

There is no clear answer to the question of who will replace Pashinyan if he resigns. Galastanyan said that this person would not be from any party. Vartan Oskanian, who served as Minister of Foreign Affairs during the Robert Kocharyan period, said that Bagrat Galastanyan is the most suitable candidate for the post of Prime Minister of the transition period .It later turned out that Galastanyan, in addition to being an Armenian citizen, is also a Canadian citizen and cannot be elected as prime minister according to Armenian consitution. Galastanyan, who confirmed that he is a Canadian citizen, hinted that he could not say no to the position of prime minister if it will be demanded:

“[But] if the people want [it], and the Armenian Patriarch will bless [it], who am I to say no? But I don’t want to.”

Certainly, these are just empty words. For Galastanyan’s ambitions to materialize, he requires more than merely 30,000 supporters and 35 deputies, along with a constitutional amendment.

Some analysts still consider the protest held on May 9 as the largest protest against Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan during his 6-year rule. This is not a coincidence either. According to the survey results announced by Gallup International, while 16% of those surveyed in March last year were satisfied with Pashinyan’s activities, this number was 8% in March this year. Although the ratings of Pashinyan, who continued to make wrong decisions after 2020, continued to decrease, the fact that he does not have a strong opponent and lack of public trust and affection towards the figures constituting the Armenian opposition are among the factors that strengthen Pashinyan’s dominance.

Hence, amid these protests, the opposition leaders opted to maintain a low profile. However, pro-Pashinyan media and Telegram channels posted videos of Galastanyan meeting with Dashnaktsutyun leader Ishkhan Saghatalyan, Robert Kocharyan’s son MP Levon Kocharyan, former defense minister Seyran Ohanyan and other opposition figures.

Furthermore, the active participation of Garnik Danielyan, a deputy of the Hayastan faction led by Robert Kocharyan, and Gegham Manukyan from the ARF, provides additional evidence that these protests were indeed organized by the opposition.

The Tavush for Motherland movement initiated by Galastanyan is supported by the most radical figures of Armenia. Among those who participated in the protests was former member of JCAG terrorist organization Hampig Sassonian, who murdered Türkiye’s Consul General in Los Angeles, Kemal Arıkan in 1982. Bagrat Sisliyan, an ASALA name who carried out the attack on the Turkish Consulate General in Paris in 1981, was among participants too.

The National Democratic Alliance (NDA), another radical group backing the protests, has surprised many by aligning with a movement supported by the pro-Russian old regime. This is unexpected as the NDA typically identifies as pro-Western and frequently stages anti-Russian protests in Armenia. Moreover, there exists a certain hostility between the NDA and the old regime.Formun Üstü

A participant of the first Karabakh war Lebanese-born Jirair Sefilian, leader of ultra nationalist Sasna Tsre was among the people gathered in the square. Sefilian, was arrested in 2016 on the grounds that he was planning to overthrow the government through an armed rebellion. His supporters of an armed group sieged the regional police station in Yerevan . The armed group demanded the resignation of President Serzh Sargsyan and tried to negotiate the release of Sefilian from prison. The hostage crisis resulted in the death of three police officers. Sefilian, on the other hand, was released after Nikol Pashinyan came to power in 2018 and was granted Armenian citizenship. However, following the developments after the Second Karabakh War, both the NDA and Jirair Sefilian, who once supported Pashinyan, are now among opposition names.

Another person who showed his support to Galastanyan was Hovhannes Hovhannisyan, the former priest of Kelbajar Khudaveng monastery. When Kalbajar was occupied in 1993, Hovhannisyan, was the first person to enter the Khudaveng monastery together with Monte Melkonyan, a member of the ASALA terrorist organization. Being also the participant of the first Karabakh war Hovhannesyan during his interview said that the hands and tongues of those who signed and said that Karabakh was Azerbaijani territory should be cut off.

Although the leader of the Armenian apolistic church, Karekin II, did not openly express his support for the protests, Bagrat Galastanyan said that he frequently met with Karekin and that he also supported the movement.

Ever since the issue of returning the four villages of Qazakh came into discussion, Armenia has witnessed a surge of opposition against it. Notably, objections were not limited to the opposition alone; few political commentators offered objective assessments. Some analysts labeled Azerbaijan’s rightful demand as land grabbing, advocating for Armenia to seek support from various countries and international organizations. However, the agreement reached on April 19 was welcomed by many countries.

Media and political analysts claimed that the villages Armenia agreed to return were from the Tavush region, causing widespread concern and confusion among the population.

As a result, nearly 30,000 people participated in the protest on May 9. However, those who took the stage and made speeches did not even mention the situation in the border villages and the concerns of the people. These people, whose attitudes are generally maximalist, clearly state that their goal is to get rid of the goverment, to stop Armenia- Azerbaijan normalization process.

Even if people are not happy with Nikol Pashinyan’s politics, they are not very keen on the return of the old regime. What the archbishop promises to the public is chaos, uncertainty, war with Azerbaijan and uncertinity in domestic politics. For now, it seems that this protest is doomed to failure, like the protests organized by Kocharyan, Dashnaktsutyun and Sargsyan supporters in 2022. Nikol Pashinyan seems to have passed another test. But he may not get what he expects in the general elections to be held in 2026. Therefore, he should be more courageous to normalize relations with its neighbors without wasting time and prove that regional cooperation and border determination are in Armenia’s interest.

Konul Shahin 

topcenter

You Might Also Like

Pakistan and Azerbaijan deepen economic ties

The Kremlin’s scenario exposed: why Russia is reinforcing its military base in Gyumri

How Karabakh is becoming a symbol of Azerbaijani success

After the crisis – a cold spell: What lies ahead for Azerbaijan–Russia relations

Khankendi becomes a turning point: The summit changed the rules of the game

AzeMedia May 15, 2024 May 15, 2024

New articles

Azerbaijan pakistan relations 1200x781
Pakistan and Azerbaijan deepen economic ties
Economy Opinion July 8, 2025
1735830384
Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, and Kazakhstan establish joint venture to launch the “Caspian Green Energy Corridor”
Energy News July 8, 2025
Israel Azerbaijan Flag 220323
Prominent US rabbi calls to include Azerbaijan in the Abraham Accords: “This is a phenomenal moment”
News July 8, 2025
H 5787782 1280
Hikmet Hajiyev: The ball is now in the EU’s court
Interview July 8, 2025
102 base
The Kremlin’s scenario exposed: why Russia is reinforcing its military base in Gyumri
Opinion July 7, 2025
1751655102 986642bab4094ba3150a3058f13e4639
How Karabakh is becoming a symbol of Azerbaijani success
Opinion July 7, 2025
1751648992122731816 1200x630
Pezeshkian faced intimidation ahead of visit to Azerbaijan
News July 5, 2025
97033886 tass 16540599
After the crisis – a cold spell: What lies ahead for Azerbaijan–Russia relations
Opinion July 5, 2025
17516265673079065174 1200x630
Khankendi becomes a turning point: The summit changed the rules of the game
Opinion July 5, 2025
D70c2eac ca02 32c8 aaca 8251b01fa4b7 850
Azerbaijan hosts historic ECO Summit in Khankendi: President Aliyev highlights regional cooperation, post-war reconstruction, and energy leadership
News July 4, 2025

You Might Also Like

Azerbaijan pakistan relations 1200x781

Pakistan and Azerbaijan deepen economic ties

July 8, 2025 9 Min Read
102 base

The Kremlin’s scenario exposed: why Russia is reinforcing its military base in Gyumri

July 7, 2025 10 Min Read
1751655102 986642bab4094ba3150a3058f13e4639

How Karabakh is becoming a symbol of Azerbaijani success

July 7, 2025 4 Min Read
97033886 tass 16540599

After the crisis – a cold spell: What lies ahead for Azerbaijan–Russia relations

July 5, 2025 6 Min Read
17516265673079065174 1200x630

Khankendi becomes a turning point: The summit changed the rules of the game

July 5, 2025 7 Min Read
Southern caucasus en.1000x0

The South Caucasus is set for geopolitical realignment

July 3, 2025 10 Min Read
Lachin seyrangah 15

Azerbaijan demonstrates strength. Khankendi hosts ECO Summit

July 3, 2025 10 Min Read
Beautiful,national,state,flags,of,iran,and,russia,together,at

Azerbaijan’s pushback against Russia and Iran is Redefining its Regional Role

July 3, 2025 13 Min Read

Useful links

426082d1 a9e4 4ac5 95d4 4e84024eb314 pojkz91103g6zqfh8kiacu662b2tn9znit7ssu9ekg
Ab65ed96 2f4a 4220 91ac f70a6daaf659 pojkz67iflcc0wjkp1aencvsa5gq06ogif9cd0dl34
96e40a2b 5fed 4332 83c6 60e4a89fd4d0 pojkz836t9ewo4gue23nscepgx7gfkvx6okbbkasqo
759bde00 a375 4fa1 bedc f8e9580ceeca pq8mvb9kwubqf6bcadpkq5mz16nayr162k3j2084cg
aze-media-logo-ag1

We are a unique political and socio-cultural digest offering exclusive materials, translations from Azerbaijani media, and reprints of articles from around the world about Azerbaijan.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookies Policy

Email: editor@aze.media

© 2021 Aze.Media – Daily Digest
aze-media-logo1 aze-media-logo-ag1
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?