By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
azemedia-new-logo
  • Donation
  • Who we are
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • News
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Ecology
  • Culture
  • Diaspora
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • Gender
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
Aze.Media
Aa
Search
  • News
  • Economy
  • Ecology
  • Energy
  • Opinion
  • Culture
  • Gender
  • Interview
  • Science
  • Logistics-Transport
  • History
  • Defense
  • Karabakh
  • Diaspora
  • Who we are
Follow US
© 2021 Aze.Media – Daily Digest
Aze.Media > Defense > The U.S. Army goes to school on Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
Defense

The U.S. Army goes to school on Nagorno-Karabakh conflict

Off-the-shelf air power changes the battlefield of the future.

AzeMedia
By AzeMedia Published March 30, 2021 11 Min Read
GettyImages-1189007244
A Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 drone flies at Gecitkale Air Base near Famagusta in the self-proclaimed Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus on Dec. 16, 2019. BIROL BEBEK/AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES

When Azerbaijan took over the skies in its fight with Armenia over the disputed enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh last fall, winning the air war with commercial Turkish and kamikaze drones, one thing started to become clear to U.S. Army strategists: It’s becoming easier to hunt and kill troops than ever before—and to do so on the cheap.

With inexpensive, combat-ready drones proliferating on battlefields all over the world, in the not-too-distant future unsuspecting soldiers might get killed just by getting out of their positions for a moment to go to the bathroom.

“You can see video of tanks being hit by an unmanned aerial system, artillery positions being hit by an unmanned aerial system, troops being hit by an unmanned aerial system,” said Col. Scott Shaw, the outgoing head of the Army’s Asymmetric Warfare Group.

What has become apparent after Azerbaijan routed Armenia last fall, he said, is that not only will the U.S. military no longer enjoy uncontested air superiority against peer rivals like China—something Defense Department officials have long resigned themselves to—but that poorer nations can buy themselves a respectable air force mostly off the shelf.

“What’s clear in that conflict is that a less funded nation can do combined arms warfare,” Shaw said. “You don’t have to be the United States or Russia. The price point to entry into combined arms warfare is lower than initially thought. You don’t need something like the United States Air Force, a superbly trained, spectacular capability, in order to conduct potentially a local air-to-ground or air-to-air activity.”

During the six-week conflict, Azerbaijan deployed Turkish Bayraktar TB2 drones and loitering munitions, many of them Israeli-made, to shrink the battlefield and chip away at Armenia’s armored forces as well as the logistical tail that hadn’t even reached the front lines.

As Azerbaijan rolled up more territory in the disputed region, propaganda videos showing the destruction of Armenian convoys and ammunition depots became a calling card of the new military approach. In the waning days of the conflict, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev even touted a laundry list of Armenian equipment purportedly destroyed or captured, including nearly 250 tanks, 50 infantry fighting vehicles, and four Russian-made S-300 missile defense systems, as well as 198 trucks and 17 self-propelled artillery units. In mid-October, Aliyev credited Turkish drones with helping his military to destroy more than $1 billion worth of Armenian equipment.

But it’s not clear how those numbers translate into truth. Shaw said the tremendous amount of disinformation flying around on open-source networks made it difficult to figure out everything that happened in real time.

It’s also still not clear to experts that drones definitively tilt the balance toward attackers or defenders. Some think that the war in Nagorno-Karabakh is another sign that the days of the U.S. military relying on overwhelming “shock and awe” bombing campaigns, like those that marked the start of both Iraq wars, are over. Instead, the United States should prepare for a knock-down, drag-out fight, similar to attrition wars of the past.

“Basically they’re telling themselves a story through convergence and military shock and awe that they’re going to be able to create effects on an opponent that we know through history simply does not happen,” said Michael Kofman, a senior research scientist at CNA and a fellow at the Wilson Center’s Kennan Institute, referring to the U.S. Army’s current operating concept for future wars.

Automation is likely to move beyond the skies, too. Shaw, an infantry officer by training, sees weaker militaries following the U.S. lead by deploying unmanned ground and sea vehicles. “If it comes by air, it’s going to come by ground and eventually by sea,” Shaw said. “These unmanned systems are just going to proliferate because they’re cheaper, and they’re just going to get smaller and smaller.”

U.S. defense planners are already moving in that direction. Mark Esper, the former defense secretary, sought to reach the Trump administration’s goal of a 355-ship Navy by investing more into research and engineering for unmanned vessels. It’s not clear yet how the Biden administration will approach the future size and composition of the fleet, but the Navy and Marine Corps released a road map for the use of unmanned systems this month.

Meanwhile, unmanned aerial vehicles are becoming more lethal. Shaw noted that drones will increasingly resemble aerial tanks—flying, armored beasts that can pack a devastating punch. And as drones become harder to kill, troops on the ground will potentially become easier to kill, with battlefield surveillance also getting cheaper. That means the Army, which hasn’t changed its camouflage face paint pattern for more than two decades, needs to find new ways to avoid being spotted, and killed, even by a weaker opponent.

That’s creating new challenges for the U.S. style of maneuver warfare. Even communication over FM radio, which was standard operating procedure for U.S. troops fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan over the past two decades, will need to be rethought as countries like Russia are getting much more skilled at locating—and striking—units that are careless about staying unmasked on the electromagnetic spectrum.

“We need to be thinking about greater camouflage than just this,” Shaw said. “You can hide a vehicle wherever you want to hide it. Here’s what you can’t hide: the tracks that go into the position, the tank tracks, the mud rucks, or whatever. Same thing with footprints. So at the tactical [level], we’ve got to figure out how to mask our movements, mask our position, mask our headquarters.”

Shaw’s unit, which spent most of the past two decades sending specially trained advisors downrange to fight threats including improvised explosive devices in Iraq and information warfare in Europe, is closing in May, part of a previous reorganization effort by then-Defense Secretary Esper last year. An Army analysis assessed the need to use the group’s resources and manpower to prep for a major-power war.

But Shaw is busy briefing other service leaders, such as Army Training and Doctrine Command chief Gen. Paul Funk, on what he and his soldiers have learned from hours of poring over footage from the Nagorno-Karabakh fight. He has brought on a historian to write a full study of the group’s history.

And he’s hoping that the lessons from the group’s 20 years in business will stay in the Army’s bloodstream, even as service leaders turn their attention away from the wars of the Middle East to deal with an increasingly assertive China—which has also disrupted U.S. planning with increasingly accurate ranged missiles. The Army, which has long enjoyed a firepower advantage in static positions, will have to think about reinventing the wheel to be a constantly mobile force, avoiding detection and incoming fire.

“If survivability moves are constant, that increases your rate of consumption for food, water, fuel. People have to sleep,” Shaw said. “We’re going to have to have leaders who are comfortable operating under the uncomfortable.”

Jack Detsch

Foreign Policy

You Might Also Like

To win in 24 hours. We did it!

Azerbaijan embarks on local antiterror measures to restore constitutional order

Azerbaijan, Israel mull defense co-op

Israel Aerospace conducts missile trial in Azerbaijan

Turkey planning to become dominant naval player in the Caspian

AzeMedia March 30, 2021

New articles

Azerbaijan-and-Israel-2023.jpg
‘We need you no less than you need us’
Opinion September 24, 2023
4aae5c28-9ce0-3abf-aca1-6ce59cfb5c19_850
Ilham Aliyev receives European Union Special Representative for South Caucasus
News September 24, 2023
p08swxlj
Matthew Bryza: Baku’s operation is an example of using military force to achieve diplomatic goals
Interview September 23, 2023
maxresdefault
Capitulation of Armenian-French illusions
Opinion September 22, 2023
279412_0
Important Statements by Hikmet Hajiyev
News September 22, 2023
379564367_630493965899258_5296033125048152371_n
When will Armenia’s new and old patrons realize who they got mixed up with?
Opinion September 22, 2023
110384
Hikmet Hajiyev: Some Karabakh militants continue to resist
News September 22, 2023
2d6302e1-84a1-3b44-8de3-dddc0501ed60
Amount of products included in aid sent to civilians living in Karabakh announced
Karabakh September 22, 2023
Orban
Hungary vetoed a joint EU statement condemning Azerbaijan.
News September 22, 2023
miroslav-jencha-oon
Azerbaijan prevented Armenian provocations, says UN Assistant Secretary-General
News September 22, 2023

You Might Also Like

Ilham-Aliyev-Mehriban-Qubadli-241220-01

To win in 24 hours. We did it!

September 20, 2023 5 Min Read
Azeri-military-in-nagorno-karabakh-scaled-1

Azerbaijan embarks on local antiterror measures to restore constitutional order

September 19, 2023 5 Min Read
8783a14a-c5b3-3d49-8926-2dba57ea34f9_850

Azerbaijan, Israel mull defense co-op

September 18, 2023 1 Min Read
מערכת_BARAK_MX_של_התעשייה_האווירית_exthgw

Israel Aerospace conducts missile trial in Azerbaijan

September 14, 2023 4 Min Read
Turkey-in-Capsian-Sept-2023.jpg

Turkey planning to become dominant naval player in the Caspian

September 6, 2023 10 Min Read
1668410224_8575816

French-Armenian tandem behind the escalation in Kalbajar

September 1, 2023 3 Min Read
thumbs_b_c_c0820b9bc6e7f1e118869a568dfff10e

President Aliyev praises Turkish-Azerbaijani military cooperation

August 27, 2023 1 Min Read
Bildschirmfoto 2023-08-25 um 15.47.07

India’s arms sale to Armenia and regional security in South Caucasus

August 25, 2023 7 Min Read

Useful links

c24a7d34-02d2-45a2-95ad-980aa8264ad5-pojkz9yv6xhhbce432wwxbxmnoy6uz3duxvaa480e8
426082d1-a9e4-4ac5-95d4-4e84024eb314-pojkz91103g6zqfh8kiacu662b2tn9znit7ssu9ekg
ab65ed96-2f4a-4220-91ac-f70a6daaf659-pojkz67iflcc0wjkp1aencvsa5gq06ogif9cd0dl34
96e40a2b-5fed-4332-83c6-60e4a89fd4d0-pojkz836t9ewo4gue23nscepgx7gfkvx6okbbkasqo
759bde00-a375-4fa1-bedc-f8e9580ceeca-pq8mvb9kwubqf6bcadpkq5mz16nayr162k3j2084cg
aze-media-logo-ag1

Aze.Media offers an independent and strategic insight on socio-cultural, political and economic life in Azerbaijan.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookies Policy

Email: editor@aze.media

© 2023 Aze.Media – Daily Digest

Removed from reading list

Undo
aze-media-logo1 aze-media-logo-ag1
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?